From US Senate to Israel’s Knesset, Arab and Muslim electoral gains open paths to influence
Muslim candidates reach record US Congress numbers as Arab parties gain leverage in Israel's government formation
From the first Muslim elected to the US Senate to record
gains for Arab-led parties in Israel, recent elections have opened new
possibilities for communities long marginalised in national politics.
In the US, Abdul El-Sayed’s victory in Michigan helped bring
the number of Muslim candidates elected to Congress to a record high. In
Israel, Arab-led parties emerged from the October 27 election with enough seats
to potentially determine who forms the next government.
While analyst Giorgio Cafiero described the US results as a
rejection of President Donald Trump’s policies towards Israel and the
US-Israeli war against Iran, Arab American Institute founder and president
James Zogby said the gains reflected decades of political organising, given
fresh momentum from the Gaza war.
In Israel, political scientist Neve Gordon said anger over
the war and other issues affecting Palestinians helped drive increased turnout,
although he warned that racism and political exclusion could limit the
influence of Arab lawmakers.
The results offer new opportunities for political
participation, but analysts say turning electoral gains into lasting influence
will depend on alliances, public pressure and overcoming resistance.
US: Muslim representation reaches historic milestone
The November 3 US midterm elections saw Democrats win
control of both chambers of Congress, while at least seven Muslim candidates
secured seats, including El-Sayed, the first Muslim elected to the Senate.
Jason H. Campbell, a senior fellow at the Middle East
Institute, said Muslim Americans remain a relatively small national voting
bloc, but their political participation has increased considerably.
Voter registration among eligible Muslim Americans rose from
60% in 2016 to 85% in 2025, according to the Institute for Social Policy and
Understanding.
"Where Muslim Americans make up higher proportions of
the population [like Michigan], they have more political influence and have
seen the benefits of increased political participation," Campbell told
Anadolu.
Zogby of the Arab American Institute said the election
results reflected decades of growing political participation among Arab
Americans, rather than a sudden shift driven solely by the Gaza war.
"The Arab American community has been growing and
maturing politically for the past four decades. We’ve been making progress all
across the country in voter registration and turnout, and in candidates running
and winning elective office," he said.
Read More: Abdul El-Sayed becomes 1st Muslim elected to US
Senate in Michigan win
"What the genocidal war in Gaza did was give greater
impetus and purpose to our growth," Zogby added, pointing also to the role
of strong candidates and campaign organisers in bringing the community's
positions to the forefront.
Cafiero, CEO of Gulf State Analytics, described the result
as a rejection of Islamophobic campaigning.
"It is clear that voters in Michigan rejected the
hateful and Islamophobic messages of Trump and Zionist extremists in America
and chose to vote for Abdul El-Sayed, representing what could be a major
turning point in American politics," he said.
Iran war, support for Israeli become liabilities
Although Muslim voters and lawmakers remain a minority,
opposition to the war against Iran extended well beyond those communities.
Cafiero linked the Democratic victories to the conflict’s
economic consequences, saying its effects on the global economy had hurt American
families and businesses.
"The success of Democratic candidates in solidly
Republican states such as Kansas underscores a widespread rejection of the
Trump administration’s wildly pro-Israel policies that brought America into a
reckless war of choice," he said.
Campbell also cited rising energy costs and broader economic
pressures, alongside dissatisfaction with the Trump administration’s immigration
enforcement policies.
The war’s political cost drew acknowledgement from the
administration itself after the vote, with both Trump and Vice President JD
Vance blaming the war for contributing to Republican losses.
Cafiero also described the election as a setback for the
American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC), arguing that its spending
against progressive candidates had failed to secure the intended results.
"This election marks a huge blow to AIPAC, which
invested massive amounts of money in candidates whom the US voters rejected,”
he said.
AIPAC spent $84.1 million through its United Democracy
Project super PAC and other political action committees, according to
Responsible Statecraft, a publication of the Quincy Institute think tank. Of
that, $55.3 million went to races in which its preferred candidate lost.
"American voters clearly rejected the US-Israeli war on
Iran and Washington’s unconditional support for Tel Aviv," Cafiero said.
Turning electoral success into policy influence
Muslim lawmakers’ influence will now depend on building alliances
with other Democrats and securing support for their legislative priorities.
When the new Congress takes office in January, Democratic
control of both chambers will create opportunities for greater oversight of the
Trump administration, including its spending decisions and military assistance
to Israel.
The results do not guarantee a fundamental change in foreign
policy, however. Congress remains divided over Israel, while the president
retains considerable authority over diplomacy and military decisions.
Zogby argued that Arab and Muslim American lawmakers would not necessarily have to persuade their colleagues individually, as changing public opinion was already putting pressure on politicians to respond.
"Public opinion has changed so significantly in the
past few years that we have the wind at our backs. So it’s not so much that we
will have impact, it’s that politicians need to respond because their
constituents are demanding change," he said.
Also Read: Democrats to investigate Trump deals, with eye on
2028 race
He added that support for changing US policy towards Israel
and Palestine now extends beyond Arab and Muslim Americans.
"Democrats will respond to us and these issues because
the majority of their supporters from all backgrounds are calling for change.
We aren’t alone anymore," he said.
Cafiero said voters will also need to hold the newly elected
Democrats accountable over the coming years.
“Now the onus is on the American voters who elected these
Democrats to pressure them into implementing the agendas they campaigned on,”
he said.
Israel: Arab parties emerge as potential kingmakers
In Israel, Arab-led parties secured their strongest combined
parliamentary representation to date. The Joint List won 11 seats and the
United Arab List, also known as Ra’am, secured eight, giving the two Arab-led parties
a combined total of 19.
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s bloc won 53 seats, while
the opposition bloc led by Gadi Eisenkot secured 48. Neither reached the 61
needed for a parliamentary majority.
The outcome has made Arab lawmakers potentially decisive in
efforts to form a new government, although their participation remains
politically contentious.
Gordon said the gains were driven primarily by anger over
the war in Gaza, alongside other issues affecting Palestinians.
"The gains among Palestinian-led political parties are
primarily due to the genocide in Gaza, alongside the widespread torture and
sexual violence against Palestinians in prisons, the settler terrorism in the
West Bank and the lack of intervention against crime within the Palestinian
communities in Israel," Gordon said.
He also pointed to the role of far-right ministers in
mobilising Palestinian voters, but cautioned that the results still fell short of
proportional representation.
"One could say that Ben Gvir and Smotrich are
responsible for the massive turnout – but we still need to keep in mind that 19
Knesset members is not 24, which is what the Palestinians should receive based
on their percentage in society," he said.
Ahron Bregman, a teaching fellow at King's College, London,
argued that excluding Arab citizens, who account for around 21% of Israel's
population, from national political decision-making could not continue
indefinitely.
"The Israelis, many liberals too, are happy to be
treated by Arab doctors and nurses in hospitals, happy to buy medications from
Arabs, many of whom own pharmacies, and visit Arab villages to eat great
Hummus, but they are reluctant to have Arabs as part of an Israeli government."
Israel: Racism and political barriers threaten lasting
influence
Gordon, a professor in the school of law at Queen Mary
University of London, said the election results could translate into greater
political influence, but warned that this would depend on how the coalition
negotiations develop and whether efforts to delegitimise Palestinian
representatives succeed.
"It could, but does not have to. Prime Minister
Netanyahu, with the help of the secret services, has launched a major
delegitimisation campaign against the Palestinian citizens of Israel and their
representatives," he said.
One possible outcome, Gordon said, would be for Palestinian
parties to support a minority government led by the opposition from outside the
coalition. In return, they could seek increased funding for schools,
infrastructure and policing.
However, he said he was doubtful that such an arrangement
would give Arab parties direct influence over Gaza policy or Israel's foreign
policy.
The negotiations are now moving into a formal stage.
President Isaac Herzog began consultations with party representatives on
Wednesday, and Ra’am announced it would recommend Eisenkot.
Gordon, however, said racism remained the main obstacle to
Arab parties joining governing coalitions, including among parties in the
opposition bloc.
"The main obstacle is racism. The second obstacle is
racism and so is third – racism," he said.
He said the opposition bloc could still cooperate with
Palestinian-led parties for pragmatic political reasons, but warned that
prejudice and discrimination would take years to overcome.

Comments
Post a Comment